Paul Weitz's "American Pie"

"American Pie" Universal Pictures. Director: Paul Weitz. Writer: Adam Herz.
Cast: Jason Biggs, Jennifer Coolidge, Shannon Elizabeth, Alyson Hannigan,
Chris Klein, Natasha Lyonne, Thomas Ian Nicholas, Chris Owen, Tara Reid,
Seann W. Scott, Mena Suvari, Eddie Kaye Thomas, Molly Cheek, Natasha Lyonne
& Eugene Levy. US 1999.
Director/Producer double act Paul and Chris Weitz follow up their screen
writing duties on last years excellent "Antz" with this stunning debut.
Together with screenwriting virgin Adam Herz they push the boundaries of the
gross out comedy even further than the Farlleys' genre defining "There's
Something About Mary". While they may not hit quite as many marks as their
illustrious predecessors they come damn close.
Imagine "Porky's" directed by John Hughes you'll be pretty close to this
tale of four high-school boys who make a pledge to loose their virginity at
the rapidly approaching high-school prom. The boys themselves are fairly
two-dimensional, Jim (Biggs) the sensitive computer geek, Oz (Klein) the
jock, Kevin (Nicholas) who's in a relationship but can't say the L. word and
Finch (Thomas) the nerdy sophisticate.
These four assorted characters are plunged into a series of increasingly
gross and occasionally touching sexual encounters, which will seem at least
vaguely familiar to anyone who has ever been a teenaged boy. It is this
element of recognition that is the films strong point, we feel the varying
emotions of these boys from adulation to humiliation as we watch their
hormones rage before our eyes and think back to a time when we were the
same.
Herz takes the familiar events of every teenaged boy's life and pushes them
just that little bit further until they reach gross without ever becoming
unbelievable. Biggs holds the film together with a deceptively strong
central performance, Klein offers fine support and Thomas steals the show
while only Nicholas fails to impress out of the central four.
If the male roles are 2D the female roles, as is so often the case with
these movie, fail even to achieve that status. There is Nadia (Elizabeth)
the foreign exchange student object of Jim's lustful affections, Michelle
(Hannigan) Jim's nerdy last chance who steals the show with one truly killer
line, Vicky (Reid) Kevin's long-term girlfriend, Heather (Suvari) the choir
girl target of Oz's new found sensitivity & Jessica (Lyonne) the spunky
sage. All however come and go, sometimes literally, without being given the
material, Michelle's one liner aside, to make much of an impression.
Scott and Owen breath some life into another pair of cookie-cutter
characters as the oafish Stifler and the other-wordly Sherman whose apparent
cherry popping antics lead to the fateful pact, respectively. Last but by
know means least are Jim's over attentive parents played by Cheek and in the
finest performance of a lacklustre career Levy.
So we have a weak story, lousy characterisations and appalling acting, but
at the same time we have some truly hilarious incidents. This is a movie of
moments and while it may ultimately prove to be far less than the sum of its
parts, some of those parts are funny enough to make the whole thing seem
somehow worthwhile.
I can think of a thousand reasons to dismiss this movie but none-the-less I
must hang my head and rather shame-facedly admit that I loved every minute
of it. Hardly ground-breaking but always hilarious this film is to be
recommended to anyone with 95 minutes to spare.

Home | Reviews | Reputations | Contact the Lizard

 

bbsban1.gif (3368 bytes)